• New Woodbarter Hats Are Available!!! Scroll down on the main page to the Member Activities & Site Support, Then click on Wood Barter SCHWAG and go to the topics on hats by Woodtickgreg to order your hat. There's only a limited quanity, so don't wait to get yours.

Router lesson

AustinTom

Member
Full Member
Messages
61
Reaction score
27
Location
Santa Fe, NM
First name
Thomas
I'm new to Woodbarter and am working my way through the threads. This one is timely since I had my first, and hopefully last, serious woodworking accident in October. I was using a router with a bottom cleaning bit and a sled to flatten a big walnut slab with a crotch section. Long story short, despite bumpers on the sides and ends of the sled to keep the router in place, taking 1/32" cuts, and completing two successful passes over the slab, the router kicked in the crotch section and on the way to the ground, routed my left wrist. Two tendons were completely cut, two were partially cut, two nerves were cut and most exciting, one artery was cut. It took 5.5 hours of surgery a couple days later to repair the damage including taking about 14" of nerve from my leg to do nerve grafts in my wrist. I have gotten back full range of motion but still waiting for feeling in my thumb and forefinger to return and still waiting for the muscle at the base of my thumb to work.

It still isn't clear exactly why it happened but several woodworking friends and I came up with these recommendations:
1) Don't use a big bit. I was using one that was about 2.5" wide. I had a 1" bit but thought that would take too long. It ended up taking 2.5 months!
2) Don't use a bit extender. I was using one which probably introduced a little extra flex that teamed up with the big bit to magnify the kick.
3) Use a router with the highest possible handles. I was using a base with low handles. This meant the bumpers on the side had to be lower. With higher handles I might have been able to resist the sideways kick.
4) Avoid using a router and sled to flatten things. I know this is a common thing to do but you won't catch me doing it again.

I hope his helps someone to avoid what happened to me.
 
AustinTom said:
I'm new to Woodbarter and am working my way through the threads. This one is timely since I had my first, and hopefully last, serious woodworking accident in October. I was using a router with a bottom cleaning bit and a sled to flatten a big walnut slab with a crotch section. Long story short, despite bumpers on the sides and ends of the sled to keep the router in place, taking 1/32" cuts, and completing two successful passes over the slab, the router kicked in the crotch section and on the way to the ground, routed my left wrist. Two tendons were completely cut, two were partially cut, two nerves were cut and most exciting, one artery was cut. It took 5.5 hours of surgery a couple days later to repair the damage including taking about 14" of nerve from my leg to do nerve grafts in my wrist. I have gotten back full range of motion but still waiting for feeling in my thumb and forefinger to return and still waiting for the muscle at the base of my thumb to work.

It still isn't clear exactly why it happened but several woodworking friends and I came up with these recommendations:
1) Don't use a big bit. I was using one that was about 2.5" wide. I had a 1" bit but thought that would take too long. It ended up taking 2.5 months!
2) Don't use a bit extender. I was using one which probably introduced a little extra flex that teamed up with the big bit to magnify the kick.
3) Use a router with the highest possible handles. I was using a base with low handles. This meant the bumpers on the side had to be lower. With higher handles I might have been able to resist the sideways kick.
4) Avoid using a router and sled to flatten things. I know this is a common thing to do but you won't catch me doing it again.

I hope his helps someone to avoid what happened to me.

Man what a tough accident. I too am glad you are able to recover from it. Sure hope you regain the feeling and the muscle for the thumb. Your words for router safety are well spoken. Thank you for sharing with us. :hi2:
 
Thanks for sharing! Sounds like a terrible injury... I hope things get back to full working order.
 
Man oh man, glad you're ok and hope your recovery is complete.

Routers are pretty scary. I'm always careful when using one, yet accidents happen. Sounds like you were maxing things out.

Graybeard
 
Yikes! Sounds like a nasty one! I don't think I've ever heard of a 2 1/2" router bit for that purpose, that sounds huge, using that under any conditions sounds a bit hairy. Hope you recover well, and get back on that horse.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7
barry richardson said:
Yikes! Sounds like a nasty one! I don't think I've ever heard of a 2 1/2" router bit for that purpose, that sounds huge, using that under any conditions sounds a bit hairy. Hope you recover well, and get back on that horse.
I've been back on the horse since January. After 7.5 months I am starting to get feeling in my thumb and forefinger. I'll probably never be 100% but expect to be at least 90%-95%.

When I finally got back to flattening that slab, I found a way to utilize a Legacy Ornamental Mill which holds the router in place. Using that bit, the same section of wood caused the router to buck quite a bit. I switched to the smaller bit to finish the job. I was doomed from the beginning but didn't know it. I guess it is the cost of an education.

BTW, they make a 3" bit. Here is a link since I am sure everyone will want one. :-)

http://www.magnate.net/index.cfm?event=showProductGroup&theID=136
 
Glad to hear that you're "back on the horse". I've been fortunate to never have a major woodworking accident in the shop and I hope that I never do. Glad to hear you're doing better.
 
AustinTom said:
I'm new to Woodbarter and am working my way through the threads. This one is timely since I had my first, and hopefully last, serious woodworking accident in October. I was using a router with a bottom cleaning bit and a sled to flatten a big walnut slab with a crotch section. Long story short, despite bumpers on the sides and ends of the sled to keep the router in place, taking 1/32" cuts, and completing two successful passes over the slab, the router kicked in the crotch section and on the way to the ground, routed my left wrist. Two tendons were completely cut, two were partially cut, two nerves were cut and most exciting, one artery was cut. It took 5.5 hours of surgery a couple days later to repair the damage including taking about 14" of nerve from my leg to do nerve grafts in my wrist. I have gotten back full range of motion but still waiting for feeling in my thumb and forefinger to return and still waiting for the muscle at the base of my thumb to work.

It still isn't clear exactly why it happened but several woodworking friends and I came up with these recommendations:
1) Don't use a big bit. I was using one that was about 2.5" wide. I had a 1" bit but thought that would take too long. It ended up taking 2.5 months!
2) Don't use a bit extender. I was using one which probably introduced a little extra flex that teamed up with the big bit to magnify the kick.
3) Use a router with the highest possible handles. I was using a base with low handles. This meant the bumpers on the side had to be lower. With higher handles I might have been able to resist the sideways kick.
4) Avoid using a router and sled to flatten things. I know this is a common thing to do but you won't catch me doing it again.

I hope his helps someone to avoid what happened to me.

:thanx: for the good news, and so good to see you are able to get up and running again. I sure hope you are enjoying your shop. :good2:
 
Glad to hear you're back at it Tom. Also thanks for that link to Magnate. Never heard of them, and I also haven't been able to find a 3" surfacing bit. I just ordered several bits from them thanks for the link.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #11
Kevin said:
Glad to hear you're back at it Tom. Also thanks for that link to Magnate. Never heard of them, and I also haven't been able to find a 3" surfacing bit. I just ordered several bits from them thanks for the link.

Magnate and Legacy Ornamental Mill (http://www.legacywoodworking.com/) have sort of partnered for years. Magnate makes some bits specifically for the mill. Since I have a mill I have been ordering bits from them for years, including custom bits. I have also been happy with their saw blades. Be careful of that bit!
 
I need to take some pics of my router planer - I've never seen one quite like it. It's my own weird concoction. It's a mammoth when set up . . . . and heavy. My router doesn't ever jump around.
 
Those bits look scary!:scare3: They look like some of the bits we use on our CNC machines at work, and those are a whole lot sturdier than a router sled!
 
Back
Top