This is actually a great subject/discussion. Mainly, for me, because when I first started doing pens, I used a friction polish finish (Shellawax...or however you spell it). Then I started using CA. The process seemed to take to long for me. Sorry, too impatient. So, I got the StickFast CA kit. Worked fairly well, and was quick, but I was having horrible crackling issues (after the fact...sometimes months later). I gave up on that, and started using WTF (WoodTurners Finish) and I get a really nice clear beautiful finish with it. The question is how will it hold up in the long term...especially compared to CA?
But this is what is interesting to me. Shellawax gives a really nice initial finish/look that I love. Eventually, it dulls making the pen 'look' less stunning. HOWEVER, I have to admit that I like the 'feel' of a pen with a friction polish better than with CA/WTF. I like the feeling of wood. Not plastic/glue.
So, I guess the answer to you the OP's question is: Use what you like. Pitch your finish as a finish that YOU chose for a specific reason. Some will/may like it. Others may not. But you can't, as they say, please all the people all the time. Bottom line is that a well made pen (good kit, turned/sanded with no marks, sanded way down to super smooth) is a good pen.