DeWalt 16 Gallon Shop Vac - Review

Nature Man

Nature Man

Member
Full Member
Messages
18,314
Reaction score
18,762
Location
Bulverde, TX
First name
Chuck
Purchased the below shop vacuum back in December 2025, just two months ago. I bought it to replace a ShopVac I had for about 10 years that burned out. About a week ago as I was using the DeWalt for about 15 minutes, it just stopped all of a sudden. Of course, I did all the things you would do when that happens, checking the position of the switch, making sure it was still plugged in, and even checked the circuit breaker. Everything was normal-normal, except the vacuum had shut down. I unplugged it and waited about 10 minutes before I retried it again. Plugged it back in and it started like a champ. Used it for about 10 minutes, and then it cut out again. Being disgusted I unplugged it and decided to give it a rest for the day. The next day it started right up, but after about 10 minutes it stopped once again. That was when I decided I had to take action, because I just can’t live with a new piece of equipment that is still in the warranty period that does not function properly. So, yesterday I took it back to Home Depot to get my money back. No problems there whatsoever. The purpose of this thread is to give anyone that is contemplating purchasing a DeWalt shop vacuum a heads up on the problem I encountered. Chuck IMG_3271.webp
 
Wow that's really strange. The 2 vacs I've purchased have been excellent without any problems. Sorry you got a bad one.
 
Sounds like the overheat button was too sensitive. Glad to hear the supplier did you right.
Give us an update on second unit if you don't mind. We tend to use DeWalt shop vacs at work. I will avoid if they are falling down on the job. We have to have continuous run for powered sanding dust collection . Sure need more than 15 minutes of sanding time.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4
2feathers Creative Making said:
Sounds like the overheat button was too sensitive. Glad to hear the supplier did you right.
Give us an update on second unit if you don't mind. We tend to use DeWalt shop vacs at work. I will avoid if they are falling down on the job. We have to have continuous run for powered sanding dust collection . Sure need more than 15 minutes of sanding time.
Click to expand...
I actually decided to not replace with another DeWalt, even though I am a big DeWalt fan. Staying with Home Depot, I opted to give the Ridgid brand a run for its money. Put it together yesterday and gave it a trial run. So far, so good. My only concern at this point is it does not have an internal collection bag for sawdust, etc. Appears to be more powerful than the DeWalt, and more noisier. Below is the comparative unit that I bought. Chuck IMG_3505.webp
 
The old guys around here will appreciate there was a time when you just bought a Craftsman and it just kept going like that little bunny. After 45 years I finally had to replace it when it died, and tried getting the Lowe’s store who carry Craftsman to replace it. Seems like there may have been a lifetime warranty on recently purchased ones, but not mine. I opted for a Ridgid, if I recall it was rated a little quieter than others. So far, I’m happy with it…but don’t expect 45 years of service. :old:
 
TimR said:
The old guys around here will appreciate there was a time when you just bought a Craftsman and it just kept going like that little bunny. After 45 years I finally had to replace it when it died, and tried getting the Lowe’s store who carry Craftsman to replace it. Seems like there may have been a lifetime warranty on recently purchased ones, but not mine. I opted for a Ridgid, if I recall it was rated a little quieter than others. So far, I’m happy with it…but don’t expect 45 years of service. :old:
Click to expand...
I loved it when Sears would take back tools and fishing rods. Dad was a manager and when returns would come back, they used to put it in back and offer it to the employees at a fraction of the cost. If careful, you could get some mighty fine items at a great price. All my rods and reels were returns. Sometimes we had to find a replacement screw or bolt, but they worked fine. Still have my Mitchel 300 that was my first open faced spinning reel, which was a return. My first fly rod - an all glass Ted Williams with Pflueger reel - I also still have. Since he was manager, he also was issued a special card which gave him/us an extra percentage off - can't remember the percentage. Could use it for all but gasoline. His store had gas pumps. My uncle who managed the appliance department, furnished his whole shop largely with returned tools - and he had almost every tool that Sears sold.
 
I have the stainless tank version of that vacuum. I got it probably 4-5 years ago direct from Stanley Black & Decker. I bought that one cause it was the top rated by Project Farm. Though my real world experience is somewhat underwhelming. It works, don't get me wrong, but it just doesn't feel like it has the sucking power that the Sears Craftsman vacs I've always ran have had. One of my biggest annoyances though is the lack of swivel in the hose. It makes using the vac a royal pain cause you're constantly fighting the hose.

About 2 years ago i dedicated it to dust collection in my shop. I was using a dust deputy, so it wasn't seeing much dust until i filled my bucket. Then came time to swap filters. I got a couple high micron DeWalt branded filters for free . There made for this exact model. I put one on and after only a couple minutes of use the motor cooked itself. There was no warning, and it never came back to life ever. In fact it's still laying on my basement floor lol. I'm certain the filter killed it.

The upside is that i contacted SBD and got sent a free replacement despite being out of warranty.. It's actually not SBD that handles it. They get their vacuums made by a third party (name escapes me at the moment). So i really should credit that company for honoring the expired warranty.. That was very nice. I still use it for dust collection, but it's dedicated to my belt sander and oscillating spindle sander only, so it doesn't see much use. I took off the high micron filter.
 
Thinking of you Chuck.

Two weeks ago the wife cleaned the school van for the start of the year. I asked if she emptied it and she said stuff was stuck in it. So I walked it over to the burn barrel to empty and found a mold forest growing inside. No clue when or where the moisture came from. The filter was just awful. So I got a putty knife and began to empty the unit. I then washed it out with rain water, being we have buckets worth from the last 2 weeks of rain nearly everyday. Use the backpack leaf blower to dry it a bit. Then it sat on the Harley a few days. Then it got a nice coat of Lysol and sat a few more days.

Yesterday the new filter arrived and I put the unit back together. Think I got 8 years out of that filter. Cleaned over 6 thousand square feet of lathe and paster removal with that thing and countless other jobs. My 16 gallon Crapsman Shop vac has been dependable for nearly 30 years (might be 25 years).
 
Mr. Peet said:
Thinking of you Chuck.

Two weeks ago the wife cleaned the school van for the start of the year. I asked if she emptied it and she said stuff was stuck in it. So I walked it over to the burn barrel to empty and found a mold forest growing inside. No clue when or where the moisture came from. The filter was just awful. So I got a putty knife and began to empty the unit. I then washed it out with rain water, being we have buckets worth from the last 2 weeks of rain nearly everyday. Use the backpack leaf blower to dry it a bit. Then it sat on the Harley a few days. Then it got a nice coat of Lysol and sat a few more days.

Yesterday the new filter arrived and I put the unit back together. Think I got 8 years out of that filter. Cleaned over 6 thousand square feet of lathe and paster removal with that thing and countless other jobs. My 16 gallon Crapsman Shop vac has been dependable for nearly 30 years (might be 25 years).
Click to expand...
And there in lies the secret. It was made before they tried to force obsolescence.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top