• New Woodbarter Hats Are Available!!! Scroll down on the main page to the Member Activities & Site Support, Then click on Wood Barter SCHWAG and go to the topics on hats by Woodtickgreg to order your hat. There's only a limited quanity, so don't wait to get yours.

help identifying?

phinds

Founding Member
Founding Member
In Memoriam
Messages
11,076
Reaction score
22,281
Location
Cortland, NY
First name
Paul
This looks like chestnut burl. I'm not saying it IS chestnut burl, since I suck at identifying burls, but it does look like it.
1740748620691.png
 
Last edited:

Arn213

craM de la craM # RipJack City!
Full Member
Messages
4,686
Reaction score
9,458
Location
Knickerbocker, NY
First name
Arn
I know certain burls have distinct visual features, profile attributes, density and/or aroma that are recognizable and they can be identified. If no one said what a specific burl was whether it was in blank form or a finished product, I am fairly certain that we as a group would not do well and get a grade “D or F” identifying burls in general. This one posted in particular, I am certain that we will not have an educated guess. Burl’s in general from the outside look’s like an elephant’s or rhino’s @$$. I don’t have an educated guess on what this is based on the photo’s, but I know for certain that this is no western big leaf.
 
Last edited:

Mike1950

Founding Member
Founding Member
Full Member
Messages
29,536
Reaction score
44,886
Location
Eastern Washington
First name
Mike
I know certain burls have distinct visual features, profile attributes, density and/or aroma that are recognizable and they can be identified. If no one said what a specific burl was whether it was in blank form or a finished product, I am fairly certain that we as a group would not do well and get a grade “D or F” identifying burls in general. This one posted in particular, I am certain that we will not have an educated guess. Burl’s in general from the outside look’s like an elephant’s or rhino’s @$$. I don’t have an educated guess on what this is based on the photo’s, but I know for certain that this is no western big leaf.
My guess is still Big leaf. Why- in 2020 alone- we were bad. Oregon and Washington had draconian mandate rules. Washington was only state that banned fishing. and in the beginning non union construction was not allowed- unions had immunity ( I know bad joke) But truth none the less.
But all that flood of money, my burl stock was shrinking so we decided we would do short day drives( 750 mi.) to keep burl stock up. First trip- Yikes- no traffic-cheap fuel. 10 trips until supply dried up.
My point- i know always long winded, not like that Arn guy and he edits. I and Jake cut 50,000+- lbs of burl that year. almost all big leaf. from dark red- called red heart to snow white brown, tans. Nobody has has a suggestion that made a real guess. If I cut a slice off that I could tell you, especially with dull blade- distinct subtle smell.
Big leaf- the weed with many faces- curl, quilt, spalt,, burl and... cheap big. the color is perfect.
Nobody is expert on burl ID in my opinion. aberrations are not east to ID. sand the end grain- it is all end grain. density- yikes Big leaf burl varies a lot in density. Burl follows no rules.
I will add picture
 

Mike1950

Founding Member
Founding Member
Full Member
Messages
29,536
Reaction score
44,886
Location
Eastern Washington
First name
Mike
you have 2 ways to ID- scientific-pores weight, dna or handle so much of it that you recognize the variations. my opinion only. I go to mill on sunday and cut 4,700 more lbs. More experience...
 

Mr. Peet

Member
Full Member
Messages
9,203
Reaction score
11,036
Location
northeastern PA
First name
Mark
I have a sneaking feeling the second piece in redbud. I may even have the rest of the tree in my shed. The cracking and the color match my stash from a nearly useless foray into slicing the tree outta my yard when it fell about 2 or 3 years back .
Works lovely with glittery epoxy according to my wife...
That is a good possibility. Redbud does often check awful in any environment. Being geometrically easy enough to work up a density, that could for sure help too. Not sure how good the colors are shown in the pictures.

 
Top