new to turning, what am I seeing?

DavidGD

Member
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Location
Silly Valley CA
First name
David
I’ve been building things out of wood for 60 years, but only tried a lathe once over a decade ago. That was a first roughing of olive cut a week earlier from trees in my back yard, on their multi-year path to being bowls. That was at a friend’s house, and it was fun to be cutting spinning wet wood … when I found the right feel. I recently have had 2 projects on my own: the first was a handle for a bottle stopper for a friend, that would also hold his family heirloom silver napkin ring, the second is an in progress bowl. Both of these used wood that had been drying for 7 to 10 years in my shop. The bottle stopper was made of walnut burl, the bowl from an ash bowl-blank. The walnut started out as a 2.5 x 2.5 x10” rectangle. It had shrunk considerably and the edges were twisted in a spiral while the surfaces were bumpy where there were no clear knots. The ash is a cube I bought, and had cut into a cylinder 10 years ago and then I waxed it.
Both were mounted to the lathe the same way: thread a steel bolt (cut off head) into the wood mount bolt shaft into chuck. In both cases I took the blank down to what I thought was very close to round (I am a beginner!) and a good shape. In both cases when I returned the next day the items were not even sort-of close to round. I could believe that the walnut was relieving stress from its drastic shrinkage, once the exterior was removed. I’m having a harder time thinking that something that was a cylinder, and with not really all that much wood removed (still a solid center), would go out of round overnight for the same reason. The ash blank spent all of its time under the unused lathe, the walnut across the shop. So it seems odd to think it a humidity change.

Thoughts?
Thanks!
 
Welcome from Bulverde, TEXAS! Definitely a problem we all face with wood, from time to time. It’s like it has a mind of its own! In your case I have to believe the wood was dry. So, think your thoughts about stress relief are probably correct, and I can’t imagine humidity being a factor based on Southern California weather. Hopefully, you can recover on these projects providing the wood objects can be shaped down some more. Chuck
 
Welcome David.

As to your issues with movement, could be several possibilities.

First, pictures always help, sometimes things pop out to others that you may not see.

As to the walnut, funky grain means funky stresses and slow moisture loss. My guess if you started with a 2.5" square worked down to an inch or a little more diameter bottle stopper, the issue was stress being released, and maybe even moisture loss.

Another consideration is how the blanks were sealed. If a blank is sealed on all sides, even after 10 years, there may still be moisture deep in the blank. When I seal blanks, I seal the end grain and an inch or two up the side grain. Slows moisture loss enough to prevent checking, but still dries with enough time.

As you probably already know, but I'll mention anyway, grain orientation matters. A cylinder, or any shape turned with grain running parallel to the bed of the lathe will warp much less than an item turned with grain at an angle to the bed.

If you suspect there might be moisture in a piece you are working, and you need to pause for a few hours or even overnight, wrap it with a plastic bag, pallet wrap, Saran wrap or something. That will reduce rapid moisture loss and warping.

Sometimes, wood will do what it wants, and the only solution is to cut it oversize, wait for it to stabilize and finish later.

Finally, sometimes we can do everything we think is right and still end up with kindling and a pile of shavings.
 
Back
Top