Wood ID help

Coloradoturner

Member
Full Member
Messages
14
Reaction score
28
Location
Colorado Front Range
First name
Scott
Does anyone know what I have here?

I've found a few chucks of it locally (have 3 or 4 once-turned bowls drying out of it and a few more to turn). It turns, and finishes really nice.

Northern Colorado front range do you can rule out any of the woods that from from really warm climates. First two pictures are of the wood in question - lighter, almost golden color, massive growth rings. Close up looks like............. elm???


elm1.webp
elm2.webp


But next 2 pictures are siberian elm, I am almost 93% sure (ha!). If these are both elm, they look and and turn nothing alike. The siberian elm below is a PITA to work with. Sanding, especially. The earlywood tends to sand down faster than the rest, leaving "relief". It takes really sharp tools and a very delicate touch with the paper. If they are both elm, they HAVE to be a different variety, I'd think. Maybe the top one grew in/near a ditch? Grasping at straws here! Both have sap wood chatoyance that lights up like a hologram in the light.

elm3.webp
elm4.webp



Thanks in advance!

--Scott
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #4
Thank you for the reply. Do you mean the TOP sample is Siberian Elm? If the top example is Siberian Elm, what does that make the bottom? Or are they are BOTH Siberian Elm, or....??

Much appreciated!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5
Someone else suggested the top example might be cottonwood, based on the color and large growth rings. We have a LOT of Plains Cottonwood around here. I think that is a possibility. But the wood grain close-ups scream "ELM!" for both, ad the top example is just a completely different animal on the lathe, and in appearance. It's crazy.
 
Someone else suggested the top example might be cottonwood, based on the color and large growth rings. We have a LOT of Plains Cottonwood around here. I think that is a possibility. But the wood grain close-ups scream "ELM!" for both, ad the top example is just a completely different animal on the lathe, and in appearance. It's crazy.
It’s ring porous. Cottonwood is not. It’s elm.
 
Back
Top